How good is Meta's Muse Image versus Gemini Nano Banana 2 and ChatGPT Images 2.5?

Edit Image A, using it as the base photograph. Remove only the large black bicycle dominating the center foreground: the bicycle with the silver handlebar, black saddle, black chain guard and bright silver front fender. Reconstruct the parts it hides—the green bicycle behind it, the painted brick wall, mortar lines, graffiti strokes, curb and paving stones—so they look continuous and physically plausible. Keep every other bicycle, every surviving graffiti mark, the crop, camera position, sunlight, shadows, texture and photographic grain unchanged. Do not add objects, text, blur, repeated wheel spokes or a visible retouching patch. Return the same landscape framing and aspect ratio as Image A.

Edit Image A, using it as the base photograph. Change only the car’s visible red-painted exterior metal panels—including the door, front fender, hood edge, rear quarter panel and the small red raised body panel above the roofline—to a deep British racing green metallic paint. The new paint must retain the original panel seams, highlights and tree reflections. Do not recolor or redesign the brown vinyl roof, chrome trim, mirrors, glass, black rubber, door handle, lock, antenna, badge, interior, driver, bouquet or background. Do not change the car model or geometry. Preserve the original crop, depth of field, lighting and aspect ratio; add no text, logo or object.

Edit Image A, using it as the base photograph. Change the scene from overcast daytime to realistic blue hour just after rain. Make the sky a clear deep cobalt-blue twilight; switch on warm interior and under-canopy lights; let those warm lights and the existing purple station band reflect subtly in the already-wet paving. Preserve exactly the same camera position, wide-angle perspective, building geometry, canopy, columns, entrances, paving layout, purple band and the readable white word “Woolwich”. Keep every existing person, bollard, poster and sign in its original location and do not add or remove anything. Do not rewrite, translate or invent text. Keep realistic dynamic range—no neon fantasy look—and return the same landscape framing and aspect ratio.

Use Image A as the base room and Image B only as the furniture reference. In Image A, replace only the narrow pale-green upholstered armchair in the back center, positioned between the two bright rear windows and partly behind the blue sofa—with the exact blue-and-gold armchair from Image B. Preserve Image B’s distinctive square blue back and seat, gilded carved wooden frame, open arms, tassel fringe and slender legs. Fit it into the original chair’s floor position and viewing angle at believable room scale; match the warm window light, floor contact shadow, perspective and any natural edge occlusion. Do not change the blue sofa, coffee table, rug, built-in window seating, lamps, windows, chandelier, wooden walls or any other part of Image A. Do not retain Image B’s gray museum background. Return Image A’s original landscape framing and aspect ratio; no extra furniture, text or collage border.

Create one square, photorealistic editorial studio portrait using all three references with strict role binding. Place the same gray tabby cat from Image A sitting upright and looking slightly left on the exact wing chair from Image B. Preserve the cat’s face, green-yellow eyes, dark forehead stripes, gray ticked coat, ear shape and long ringed tail. Preserve Image B’s high winged back, rolled arms, broad seat, curved front legs and dark lower crossbars, but replace only its upholstered fabric with the exact Strawberry Thief textile from Image C: navy ground, mirrored thrushes, red strawberries, blue leaves and pink flowers, at a scale where at least two complete birds are visible across the chair. Use a seamless warm-gray studio background and soft light from upper left with coherent contact shadows. Do not copy foliage or ground from Image A, the archival backdrop from Image B, or a rectangular swatch from Image C. No collar, costume, extra animal, extra furniture, text, border or collage panels.

Use Image B as the base destination photograph and Image A only as the identity reference for my daughter. Create a convincing family travel photograph placing the same young girl from Image A on the snowy ski slope in Image B, with Hokkaido’s Mount Yotei, horizon, ski runs and blue winter sky preserved exactly. Show her full body in the left foreground, smiling naturally toward the camera, wearing an age-appropriate red ski jacket, navy snow trousers, black gloves, white ski boots and a cream knitted hat that leaves her face fully visible. Place two child-sized skis parallel beneath her boots and one pole in each hand. Match the mountain light, camera height, scale, crisp cold air, snow contact shadows and reflected blue light. Preserve her age, face, eye color, hairline and recognizable expression; do not adultify or beautify her. Do not change the mountain silhouette, add buildings, invent text, duplicate people or create a collage. Return Image B’s landscape framing and aspect ratio.

Use Image A as the base photograph. Replace only the adult woman seated behind the man on the scooter with the adult woman from Image B. Preserve the new woman’s recognizable face, eyes, nose, mouth, complexion and long dark hair, but adapt her naturally to the original passenger’s seated pose, scale and gaze. She must wear the original passenger’s cream cardigan and beige skirt and hold the same twin-lens camera in the same position with plausible hands. Do not bring across Image B’s conical hat, red scarf, flag, street or background. Keep the man completely unchanged—including his face, hair, blue striped shirt, hands and riding posture—and preserve the scooter, chrome rack, cobblestones, landmark building, gates, plants, signs, shadows, crop and depth of field from Image A. Match the existing midday sunlight and contact shadows so this looks like one unedited travel photograph. Do not alter any other person or object, add jewelry or text, duplicate limbs, blur faces or create a collage. Return Image A’s landscape aspect ratio.